Today for the first time Rachel must go to school with a yellow star on her coat, a big yellow star, with the word Jew written in the middle of it. Thus everyone can see that she is Jewish. The Germans have ordered the wearing of the star, and Rachel finds it horrible.
All her mother did yesterday evening was sew stars on their clothing. "I see stars," Mother said, and they even had to laugh about it.
"I'll take you to the tram," says Papa. "Come on, hurry up, otherwise you'll be late for school."
They put their coats on. How big the star is. Esther's star is even bigger than Rachel's. "It looks that way because Esther has such a small body," their father explains. "That's why her star seems larger."
When they arrive at the tram stop they see many other people with stars on, grown-up people and little people. "All Jews," an old man says. "Yesterday I did not know they were Jews, although I suspected they were."
"You must hold your schoolbag under your arm as you usually do, not against your star," Father admonishes her. Rachel blushes. Father saw that she was trying to hide her star.
"It's difficult, but if you don't hide your star now, you'll get over the embarrassment more quickly. When the war is over, we'll make a huge fire and we'll throw all the stars of the whole world into it."
"Boy, will that stink!" Rachel exclaims.
"It stinks right now," Leo says. "I smelled the star when I put my coat on."
"Children, here comes the tram," Father calls.
The moment has come. For the first time Rachel will have to go on the tram with that horrible star.
"Come in!" the driver of the tram calls out to them. "It really is springtime in my tram now. All these children with yellow daffodils on their coats. I wish I could wear one."
When they are all inside, many people begin to clap, just as an audience does at the end of a play. Rachel does not understand. A man nudges her. "Bow, the clapping is for you, for your stars."
Rachel does not dare to move. What is that? Are the people clapping for that big yellow star? The children look at one another. "They are clapping for us," Leo says, and he begins to bow. "Thank you, people. Thank you very much."
A few people do not clap, but look straight ahead instead. Leo approaches one of those people. "Ma'am, would you like a star, too? Tomorrow I'll bring you one. Would you like a star, too, mister?"
"Go away, you little Jew boy," the man replies, and to the woman sitting next to him he says, "You can't cut them down to size. Not the big Jews and not the little ones, either."
Source: Hide and Seek by Ida Vos. Copyright © 1981 by Ida Vos. Excerpted by permission of Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.
This story is told from early in the war, before the Jewish people were being deported to the ghettoes and the camps.
We meet quite a number of people in this brief story: Rachel, her mother, her father, her sister Esther, an old man, her brother Leo, the tram driver, a man on the tram. What are the different feelings that they have about the Star and about the Jews in general?
Why might a Jewish child feel differently about having to wear the Star as opposed to an adult?
some different feelings are:
ReplyDelete-Think its a good thing
-the star is looked as negative to the older people and call the boy "little jew boy" which is negative
-the little girl feels embarassed
-the bus driver looks at it posotively and calls them flowers.
the child could feel differently because they might not no what the star means and what it stands for (that they are lower than the German citizen). the adult might feel differently because they might have a better understand of what the star represents and the digrimination that comes along with wearing the star
A star on a child seemed bigger because they were smaller. This made it harder for the younger kids because it seemed embarrassing.It was embarrassing to have to wear a star in general, it did not matter if you were a child or adult, it was degrading. What wear the Jews suppose to do, they did what they had to to survive. The Jews hatted the stars that they wore, it made them feel worthless and pointless.
ReplyDeleteTo some of the people, mostly the children, it was embarrassing it wear just large stars on their clothes, it was alien and just out of place. The children saw it as that and not as the adult saw it. The adults knew that the purpose of the stars or others that didn't found them suspicious. At the beginning many found it proud to declare that they were Jewish, that wearing the star was a symbol of themselves. It is obvious to tell that a child in these circumstances would see it differently then an adult because they don't really have a full understanding of what it means.
ReplyDelete1. Some people were embarrassed like Rachael, some people were proud because they are not going to let other people diminish them, some people were glad that people were putting up with this like the bus driver putting it in a better light for Rachael
ReplyDelete2. The children are probably more nervous not full under standing what is happening.
some people mostly children thought it was embarrassing to wear the star because it looked really big (because of there bodies)
ReplyDeleteother people said that the Jewish people would get used to it after awhile and there was no point in hiding it
they might feel singled out like there is something wrong with them or they have done something bad and they have been forced to were the star to tell every one when they are and that for some stupid reason that they are worthless
ReplyDeletethere are many diffent feelings her father is not embarssed rachle is mortafid leo thinks that it is ok there are people on the train that clap then the man who is rude to the like boy leo the driver thinks that the star are great.
ReplyDeletethe chilend were more embarssed just like at school noone wants to be the on standing out they think that it is a bad thing they are wearing it they are embareds to be jewis
som of them are ok weth the seen the star. and som are noet sher. ehter people haet thet thae are joes becoes. the gelden are efred thet people well haet them joej. enoer have no respeckt fo them geve. them haerd tiems het them fecle and metle.
ReplyDeleteWell the childerning did not like having the star on their cotes, The Jewish adult didn't like it eather but keep that to them self and tried to cheer up the like kids.
ReplyDeleteThe woman and the man on the tram did not like them and know who was Jewish and who was not.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletehey :)
ReplyDeleteDifferent people have different opinions about the stars. A jewish child might feel differently about the star than adults because a child might either be innocent or just unaware of what the star means.
ReplyDelete